Political Self-Examination…….

The Christian tradition (and we are certainly not alone in this) has long sought to emphasize the value of regular self-examination.  In the Book of Common Prayer, as part of the annual Ash Wednesday service, the congregation is invited to consider Lent, in part, a time of “self-examination and repentance.”

The two do indeed belong together.  For the true meaning of the word “repentance” is “to turn around”, with the implication that having turned around, one is to head in a different direction.  Far from the popular dreary notion of beating one’s self up for one’s sins and feeling very sorry for it, repentance is the positive process of recognizing where we need to make changes, and dedicating ourselves to starting over, to beginning a new and more healthy chapter.  One cannot really do that, however, if one is unaware of the places in life where changes do need to be made.  And that awareness is the fruit of self-examination.  To examine one’s self is to be willing to face the truth of one’s life honestly.  It does not mean to be undeservedly hard on one’s self.  But it does mean looking at one’s life with both love and honesty.

Self-examination and repentance are not only good practices for individuals.  They are also good practices for organizations and communities.  Just as people have places in their lives where changes need to be made and new beginnings launched, so do groups.  I have been thinking a bit about this in the wake of our recent national elections.   Regardless of how you voted, the results of all of our voting brought one party success and the other much less success.  In the aftermath of these results, a great many leaders of the Republican Party have been trying to explain their disappointment.   They have sought to place blame in various different places.  What has been fascinating to me as I have watched this blame game unfold is the reluctance that most of the Republican leadership seems to have to actually engage in the time-honored practices of self-examination and repentance.  When things don’t work out the way we expected them to, sometimes it is indeed because of forces beyond our control.  But sometimes (and more often than we probably like to admit), the results have to do with us:  things we said or didn’t say, things we did or didn’t do.  It is a very natural thing to want to find a scape-goat for our problems, someone or something that we can use to assure us that we have no need to change – rather, our problem is entirely due to someone or something else.  But if we devote all our energies to finding a scape-goat (or many scape-goats), then we won’t have much left to devote to looking at ourselves.  And that usually means we miss something crucially important.

This is not really a blog post about Republicans, nor is it really about Democrats, either.  The reaction of most Republican leaders in the wake of the election simply provides a good real-life example of a problem that afflicts us all to some degree, that afflicts most organizations, and that seems to afflict politicians to a considerable degree.  And that is our reluctance to really look at ourselves, to see ourselves both in love and honesty, and recognize where we need to change.

It takes a certain courage, a certain strength of heart, to do the work of self-examination and to follow that up with genuine repentance – true change.  But if we are willing to find that courage, the fruit of these practices both for us as individuals and for the organizations to which we belong can be abundant, indeed.

4 thoughts on “Political Self-Examination…….

  1. I would even broaden your point and suggest that, in a democracy, the people get, not simply the government , but also the politics they deserve. The often trivial, usually absurd and enexcapable veniality of the recently completed election cycle is something we all, as citizens of this country need to reflect upon and about which much repentance is well past due.

  2. I totally agree with your assessment…but it is a problem with all Americans.
    We seem to be unable to accept responsibility for ur shortcomings! Thanks
    For your take on this. Kitti

  3. I don’t know if my comment was posted, but as I said earlier, it seems that this reluctance to accept responsibility for our actions and their consequences is endemic in the population of the U.S. How do we begin
    To help the nation to understand the necessity to accept (with gentleness)
    That sometimes we make a mistake.
    Thanks, Kitti

  4. I’ve been thinking a lot about the election and the respective failings of both sides of the partisan divide, and I can’t escape the conclusion that American politics is plagued, across the political spectrum, by a radical individualism. As Americans, we tend to view independence and self reliance as ideals to which we aspire, and there’s no denying that, in proper measure, they are virtuous qualities, but all heresies – all lies, in fact – consist not of complete and utter falsehood, but in the corruption of something true. It is a twisting out of shape, a removal from proper context until truth ceases to accurately reflect reality. In our national fetishization of individuality, elevating it as an absolute value over all others, we deny the even greater, essential virtue of community.

    On the political right, we see it manifest negatively, in an “I don’t wanna” individualism. “I don’t wanna pay taxes. I don’t wanna help the poor. I don’t wanna submit to rules.” It is a revolt against external impositions like duty toward our neighbor. Patriotism is reduced to sentiment and citizenship is rejected in favor of autonomy.

    The political left, conversely, is consumed by a formulation in which the individual will is the ideal. Freedom is mistaken for liberty, and choice eclipses responsibility. Prohibition in the name of community is construed to unjustly limit personal expression/actualization. This doesn’t describe all, or even most conservatives or liberals, it describes only those at the extremes, but in a sign of the deep immaturity of our politics, it is the extremes that are allowed to frame the terms a discussion that promises not merely the infallibility of our own viewpoint, but the absolutely catastrophic error of our opponents.

    Philosophically, our national political debate boils down to a contest between those who don’t wanna eat their vegetables or share their toys, and those who wanna stay up late. Is it any wonder that American democracy has become so divided and so often plumbs the depths of absurdity?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s